
SOCIAL MOBILITY
Dismantling barriers

The IP sector is still struggling to achieve true socioeconomic diversity due to the limited paths into the profession, says Declan Cushley of Browne Jacobson.
Those of us who have spent many years in the IP profession have often noted how privileged we are to be part of such a tight-knit network which forms the sound basis for an interesting and continually challenging profession.
However, I am not sure many of us have ever actually challenged that sense of privilege: does it present a challenge to all of us to be part of making our profession as diverse and inclusive as possible?
Not only is that absolutely the right thing to do, but a real collective effort on all our parts to accelerate each of our firm’s socioeconomic diversity will undoubtedly present an even broader platform for diversity of innovation, thought and the inevitable business positives that will follow.
One might argue that we already have a diverse profession particularly when it comes to the balance of opportunities around gender but it is worth looking a little deeper, beyond the published glossy annual people and diversity reports.
There remains one particular barrier that continues to mean accessing a career in the IP profession (like many others) can feel attainable only to a limited few, and not the talented many. This aspect of diversity can be found lurking in the shadows, continually dismissed as a non-priority or (in some cases) a complete ‘myth’—socioeconomic diversity.
While many firms have made great strides in driving increased levels of socioeconomic diversity and representation across various legal disciplines, our profession still faces significant challenges in achieving ‘real’ socioeconomic diversity.
This article explores the importance of socioeconomic diversity in our profession and considers why addressing this issue is crucial for our future. It hopefully offers some ideas and initiatives that we have found are beginning to make a real difference at Browne Jacobson.
The underlying issue
Socioeconomic diversity refers to the representation of individuals from various economic backgrounds within a particular profession or field. In the context of the IP profession, it encompasses the inclusion of attorneys, lawyers and other professionals from diverse economic and social backgrounds.
Historically, our profession has typically (but not exclusively) attracted applications from individuals from ‘professional’ socioeconomic backgrounds (with Oxbridge or Russell Group University degrees) due in part to the high costs associated with education and training and the bias of many firms towards hiring from a limited pool of particular universities. For example, in 2022 the top 100 UK law firms hired 84% of their trainees from Russell Group Universities.
There are clearly institutional barriers which are negatively impacting socioeconomic diversity in the broader profession and of course, the key long-term solution is to significantly increase the number of working-class STEM and law students. But that is a change that will take time and significant resources, and will need to be an ongoing effort for a number of years. There are other steps that we can all consider if we are to accelerate the pace of change.
”If a student has a parent or guardian who is a lawyer, they are 17 times more likely to become a lawyer themselves.”
Socioeconomic diversity in the IP landscape is not just a matter of fairness and opportunity for all, it has to be a strategic imperative for several reasons:
To be truly innovative and progressive we need diverse perspectives. Our profession plays a pivotal role in protecting innovation and creativity. A diverse group of professionals brings these varying perspectives to any business and will not only enhance the quality of solutions of legal counsel, but will provide a sound platform for innovation itself.
Client representation
Clients come from a multitude of backgrounds and industries. To provide effective authentic counsel and communication, we should take time to understand the socioeconomic backgrounds of all our clients and take a serious and deeper look at the barriers that they may have faced and have overcome. It seems like an obvious step to best achieve this by working with a diverse socioeconomic team from within, as nothing beats having common ground to refer back to.
Access to justice
Socioeconomic diversity in the profession can improve access to legal services, making IP protection more attainable for individuals and startups with limited resources.
Diversity of thought leads to greater and higher quality innovation. Diverse employees have access to more diverse networks, their lived experience can provide an invaluable perspective to any new situation or opportunity. Despite these obvious benefits, the IP professions continue to track some way behind, not only in terms of socioeconomic diversity, but also on gender and, in particular, racial diversity.
Barriers to entry
Several factors are contributing to the limited socioeconomic diversity within our professions. The high cost of legal education can deter (and ultimately prevent) individuals from lower-income backgrounds from pursuing a career in law. Make no mistake, these individuals have the talent and the dedication required to be highly successful, it’s simply unattainable and unrealistic based on the financial resources available to them. That’s talent the profession has lost.
Many IP opportunities, such as internships, are unpaid or, at best, low-paid, making them financially inaccessible to those who cannot afford to work without adequate financial compensation. When it comes to advancing social mobility, offering unpaid work experience opportunities actually widens the socioeconomic gap more than if you don’t offer work experience at all.
of the top 100 UK law firms hired their trainees from Russell Group Universities in 2022
Source: Social Mobility Employer Index
Did you know that if a student has a parent or guardian who is a lawyer, they are 17 times more likely to become a lawyer themselves? Parents and their professional contacts play a crucial role in the career advancement of their offspring. Individuals from lower socioeconomic backgrounds often lack access to influential networks, and thus opportunities, putting them at a further disadvantage.
Bias of course comes in many forms, but in recruitment it ultimately boils down to being influenced, positively or negatively, by pre-conceptions or personal opinions that aren’t relevant to the hire. For example candidates with lots of work experience on a CV (often as a result of their parents’ network, and even if the work experience isn’t actually relevant) are often hired into entry level positions over lower socioeconomic background candidates whose CVs contain no experience (they often have no network to utilise).
Solutions and strategies
If we’re really going to make significant headway on the issue of socioeconomic diversity and change the IP landscape, then a multi-faceted approach is needed:
The phrase ‘if you can’t see it, you can’t be it’ has never been so true. Due to COVID-19, work experience and careers fair events ground to a halt meaning visibility of (and access to) career paths and opportunities has never been harder. The post-COVID world has seen a number of firms embrace the use of technology and many now host career insight and virtual work experience events on a mind-boggling scale. At Browne Jacobson our first virtual insight event under our flagship social mobility led programme FAIRE (Fairer Access Into Real Experience) was attended by 7,120 students in 2020. We expected a few hundred and were both surprised and more motivated than ever to try and make a difference.
Apprenticeship programmes are quickly becoming the favourite path of Generation Z and law firms and our profession needs to think again about how we can establish apprenticeship programmes to support individuals from underrepresented socioeconomic backgrounds who can’t afford to go to university (and the associated costs) access and gain an IP education.
”Creating mentorship programmes and facilitating networking opportunities can help level the playing field for aspiring IP lawyers from lower socioeconomic backgrounds.”
Mentorship and paid-for opportunities
Creating mentorship programmes and facilitating networking opportunities can help level the playing field for aspiring IP lawyers from lower socioeconomic backgrounds who don’t have the professional networks and opportunities. It’s not giving an advantage; it’s simply removing the disadvantage they were born into.
Our entire profession should seriously consider offering properly well-paid opportunities to ensure that economic constraints don’t limit access to valuable experiences that will significantly boost the career prospects of those who undertake them. No one should be placed into a position when they can’t afford to undertake work experience. Via our multi award-winning FAIRE programme we offer 80 paid placements per year, regularly collaborating with our clients’ legal teams to offer a best-in-class experience where students can gain experience in both private practice and in-house.
Inclusive hiring practices
At Browne Jacobson we completely anonymise CVs—there’s no reference to gender, ethnicity, academic grades, academic institution attended, no mention of interests or hobbies etc. We also no longer apply grade thresholds (for example we don’t ask for a 2.1 or above classification). In addition we’ve rolled out unconscious bias interview training for our hiring managers, ensuring the best possible care is taken to eliminate any bias. We’ve seen the percentage of hired junior lawyers from lower socioeconomic backgrounds change from 11% (2016) to 41% (2023).
In-house lawyers and the purchasers of legal services have the chance to hold their panel law firms to account by asking questions (during the bid/ tender process) about the actions they are taking to advance socioeconomic diversity within their own workforce. We should all act now in order to be able to answer those questions effectively.
Conclusion
Socioeconomic diversity isn’t just a buzzword: it’s a critical component of a thriving and inclusive IP profession. Embracing socioeconomic diversity broadens perspectives, enriches legal counsel, and ensures that innovation and creativity flourish in a fair and equitable manner. By acknowledging the barriers to entry and implementing proactive strategies, we can all pave the way for a more diverse and promising future for our profession.
Declan Cushley is head of corporate sector strategy and Browne Jacobson’s UK&I Intellectual Property team. He also sits on the firm’s partnership board. He can be contacted at: declan.cushley@brownejacobson.com
Image: Shutterstock / vectorfusionart, Vasin Lee